Three-Cheese Stuffed Shells

I have very clear memories of eating stuffed shells as a kid, made by my lovable but mob-connected Uncle Vincenzo. Just kidding they were frozen TV dinners. I did my best to heat them up properly, but there would always be at least one bite of ice cold ricotta or tomato. It really just ruined the whole thing. Little kids aren’t great with microwaves, or much else if we’re being honest.

I wasn’t planning on making this dish but the amount of leftover cheese in my fridge was becoming worrisome. I started this recipe thinking it would be an incredibly easy way to clean out my fridge, and it was, but it was also a huge mess. This is partly because the largest pasta shells available at my awful grocery store were smaller than expected. If you want to limit the amount of work you have to do, I’d recommend using bigger shells. Regardless, ricotta will be all over your hands and maybe other areas if you aren’t careful. Cheese in special places will be worth it though, because these are crazy delicious.

  • About 15 “large” pasta shells
  • 1 cup ricotta cheese
  • 1/2 cup grated¬†Parmesan cheese
  • 1 cup diced fresh mozzarella cheese, with some left over for topping
  • 1 24 ounce jar of tomato sauce
  • 2 eggs
  • 1/4 cup fresh parsley, with some for garnish if you’re fancy
  • 2 teaspoons black pepper

Preheat your oven to 350 degrees.

stuffed shells recipe
“Jumbo” shells, we’ve all heard that before, am I right ladies?

Boil the shells until they are slightly under-cooked. I took them out about two minutes earlier than I normally would, and after the baking process they were perfect.

stuffed shells recipe
Look at those snot bubbles in the egg white. Yum!

Stir up all the cheeses, parsley, eggs, and black pepper. Per usual I didn’t measure anything, I just used everything I had. It’s a mixture of cheeses, you probably won’t screw it up.

stuffed shells recipe
Uncle Vincenzo would say this looks like baby vomit. What a guy!

Resist tasting the mixture because it’s full of raw eggs and probably salmonella. This will become harder in two steps.

stuffed shells recipe
The tomato sauce of the bourgeois

Pour a layer of sauce in a glass pan. I went with Prego’s Mushroom sauce, shelling out a whole 75 cents more than the generic brand because I’m a grown ass woman.

stuffed shells recipe
Stuffing station

This is the messy part during which you will be tempted to lick raw egg off your fingers. Fill the shells with a big spoonful of the cheese mixture. The shells ideally will hug the cheese nicely.

stuffed shells recipe
The Dove Campaign for Real Stuffed Shells

But sometimes that doesn’t happen. As long as the majority of the cheese is inside the pasta, it will be fine.

stuffed shells recipe
Uncle Vincenzo would often come home from work with “red sauce” all over his shirt. He’s so silly!

Pour sauce over all the shells. I used the entire can plus a little leftover pizza sauce that I found in the back of my fridge, apparently from three weeks ago. I’ll tell you how that works out.

stuffed shells recipe

Cover the pan with foil and bake at 350 degrees for 30 minutes. Then remove the foil, sprinkle with the remaining mozzarella, and bake for an additional 10 minutes.

stuffed shells recipe

The sauce should be bubbling at this point, confirming that there are no random frozen chunks hidden beneath the surface. Spoon yourself a bowl and get eating. These stuffed shells are so delicious and I can’t wait to eat them in front of my coworkers.

stuffed shells recipe


stuffed shells recipe


Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *